Hi Jim,
You wrote in part -
"First, no matter how much SEO you do, there can be only one #1 ranking for a keyword, one #2, etc.."
True... but you can gain rankings for mulitiple search phrases by following sound SEO techniques on different pages of your site. And as Dirk wrote, "A fraction of the time spent blogging and commenting could be applied to focused SEO work, probably with dramatic results." It would not be that hard to climb the organic rankings ladder into the Top 10 to Top 30 listings for various targeted keyword phrases if the time spent writing posts to a blog was spent instead on SEO.
You went on -
"Second I have a lot of subscribers to my blog that apparently read most every post and comment back to me pretty often; I love that sort of interaction with potential buyers and sellers before they actually become buyers & sellers. Great top of mind awareness."
Jim, I think your blog might just be the exception rather than the rule. Many agents spend a lot of time trying to build a blog that ends up not being as successful as yours. Oh, blogging can have it's place, as I wrote back privately to Bonnie below -
-------------------------
For most major metropolitan areas (and Denver would certainly qualify), there are very few blog sites that rank as high as web sites.
I did what I recommended you do - test the theory. I just went to Google and did a search for Denver Real Estate. (I found your site at #18 today by the way). I have now clicked on every agent's site in the Top 30 (weeding out the sites like realestate.yahoo.com, realtor.com, trulia.com, etc.) There are 16 agent or company sites in the Top 30... and the only one that is a blog site instead of the web site is http://www.kristalsellsdenver.com. Can a blog site rank? Sure. But it certainly is a lot harder, as evidenced by this 5 minute look at Google, than doing it the other way with a wonderful web site.
While blogging can be a good adjunct to a very good web site and help to drive in extra visitors to it, I have found so far that most people really don't care about reading a real estate agent's blog posts. They just want to search for properties! That might be because many, many agents are just not good writers. ;-) We make our living by giving oral presentations - not written ones. If we were so good at writing, we would probably be in a different profession.
"Dynamic vs. static" has little to nothing to do with rankings in Google. I have many web clients in the Top 10 to Top 30 in Google for their targeted search terms and I can honestly say, some of them have not changed 1 word of text on their site in 3 to 5 years or even longer. (How would I know? I'm the one who puts up new content for them. My sites are not templates!) Yet these agents stay at the top of Google month after month and keeping getting terrific leads that end up turning into closed real estate transactions. These same agents who are doing all of this business don't blog at all! So from where I sit, and based upon the experience of my web clients, the concept that one needs to be adding new content all the time to their web site in order to get found or to achieve high rankings truly is an "urban myth"! And if that is true, it also then poses the question, "Why blog?" Unless you just like sitting in front of the computer and being a creative writer, my experience shows it just isn't necessary at all.
So whether you ever use me as a web designer or not, I just didn't want to see you fall backwards from the very nice rankings you already have by heading off to strictly a blog site instead of a nice web site and then possibly regretting it later.
-------------------------
I agree that it can be nice to blog, if you can gain an audience, like you have Jim. But is it necessary? No.
Regards,
Win
************************
Win Singleton, CRB, e-PRO
Summit Web Design
(703) 536-7631
wins@summitweb.com
http://Summitweb.InternetCrusade.com
an Internet Crusade Approved Vendor
"Custom web site design that gets results!"
************************