The real estate industry provides an invaluable service for the public – it provides the rules of the road.
At the four-way intersection are lenders, real estate brokers, consumers. They all want the same thing – for housing sales to go through the green light safely.
The system works pretty well as long as the majority follows the rules. It’s called cooperation.
But, REOs and short sales have put too many cars on the road. They’re creating wrecks and clogging the roads because their drivers – banks - don’t follow the same rules of traffic as the real estate industry.
In communities where distressed sales are 50 percent of the market, the congestion goes on for miles. Read that as months of inventory on hand.
That’s the analogy Jeremy Conaway, real estate association consultant, came up with to show his AE clients what they can do to fix the housing market at the local level.
“If nobody knows what the rules are, traffic congestion (unsold houses) is going to get worse,” says Conaway, founder of Reconis.com. “Associations need to call for a summit and get the banking industry, housing authorities, city government leaders and establish new rules for cooperation.”
The lack of cooperation between the banking industry and the real estate industry is hurting all involved. Here’s how:
- Banks are willing to lose money on a foreclosure even if they have a sale for the home because no loss mitigator is a hero for losing the bank money.
- Homes allowed to go into foreclosure bring down prices on the rest of the market, a cause-and-effect banks don’t seem to understand.
- Homebuyers aren’t clear how to buy these “bargains.” Who do they call? The homeowner? Customer service? A Realtor?
- Buyers can get a loan approval in minutes, but the bank approval for a short sale may take months.
- The real estate industry isn’t trained to deal with the influx of short sales and foreclosed homes to the marketplace. They don’t know who to call either.
- Because banks aren’t members of the MLS, cooperation has to be worked out deal by deal, clogging the market further.



















Comments
Comment by: Bonnie Cox
- Jan 14, 2009 11:04:14 PMI think there is going to be more pressure put on lenders to help families avoid foreclosure either through a GOOD loan modification for a homeowner that qualifies. If the homeowner wil still not be able to make payments, then a short sale can be an option. The trouble with many of the buyers we have had interested in a home that was a preforelosure is the listing agent and the homeowner had not properly prepared and submitted documentation to the lender's loss mitigator. There must be a hardship letter, a financial statement, pictures of the home, and the home must go immediately on the market. The price must be lowered every two weeks until a buyer is found. It is possible to stall the foreclosure if the possibility of a qualified buyer is real. Handled correctly, a short sale is cheaper for the lender and far less onerous on the homeowners credit than a foreclosure. Still, there will be tax implications and possibly a deficiency judgement.
Comment by: Sean Goerss
- Jan 15, 2009 9:14:20 AMBlanche, good article, and good analogy.
I think it may be hard to get all of those parties on board with changing the rules - the market will probably work itself out before that happens.
Instead, what I see happening, is these short-sale negotiation companies popping up - they specialize in "greasing the wheels" between the banks and the market (agents and buyers).
Yes, many will criticize those types of companies for negotiating a profit margin between the negotiated price with the bank and the offered price from the buyer - but they are providing a necessary "lubrication" of the deal-making process in real estate, and therefore are creating extra value in the market.
I know several top agents here in the Twin Cities who absolutely have this short sale stuff NAILED DOWN with using short sale negotiation companies - they are thriving, the banks who decide to work with them are thriving, the sellers are getting out of their houses in 1-2 months instead of 8-9 months or foreclosure - everybody is winning - but you have to be smart enough to join up with the right partners.
I think you will see these types of negotiating companies, who have working with banks down to a science, be used more and more by savvy real estate agents.
Sean Goerss
Realtor, St. Paul, MN
www.RealEstateTechnologyExperts.com
Comment by: Blanche Evans
- Jan 15, 2009 10:11:20 AMI'd like to know more about these short sale negotiation companies. Whatever helps at this point should be welcome, because it's clear that the banks and the real estate industry aren't communicating very well.
Comment by: Douglas Harbin
- Feb 19, 2009 2:10:18 PMI formed a company 18 months ago to specalize in short sales. The process is very tedious and frustrating, but at the same time very rewarding. Helping someone avoid the stress and other emotions that go along with a foreclosure keeps me going. It makes all the education, training and long days of dealing with many lenders worth all the effort. What we have found in our dealings with the mitigators is that they want to deal with someone on the other end of the negociation who has experience and can get these deals off their desk. Many agents do not have the time and, quite frankley, do not want to deal with short sales. I do see a trend recently with the lenders that they are becoming more accessable and more willing to look for solutions to this ever growing problem.
Douglas Harbin
Realtor, Broker
Comment by: RichardHansson
- Apr 25, 2009 1:04:01 PMHi,
I agree with your article. I'd like to add a little more to your article. It is all the reasons you listed in your posting that the inventory isn't moving but it's going to get worse depending on the outcome a recent ruling on foreclosures. How about a retro-active re-foreclosure market. I've written a blog posting on it and hope you check it out. It's bound to stall the market even further! I've also written about the short sale market as well.
Great post!
Post a Comment