Welcome to the New RealTown! Submit Feedback
Member Login | Join RealTown
The Real Estate Network

Manhattan Loft Guy

New York, New York

on matters of interest to Manhattan coop or condo loft apartment dwellers, buyers, sellers, and others, especially about New York City real estate

Subscribe

Your E-mail Address:
Subscribe to:

Recent Comments

http://www.elegantugg.com/
<a href="www.elegantugg.com">ugg b...
RE: do any of you people know how to pray?
You are sharing most useful information. Now a day...
RE: Zillow - what it is and what it says about how it does Manhattan
    EVEN MORE PERFECT...WILL BUY <a...
RE: Zillow - what it is and what it says about how it does Manhattan
  I bought one kids <strong><a href...
RE: Zillow - what it is and what it says about how it does Manhattan
  <a href="http://www.maxugg.com/&qu...

Site Feed

RSS Feed

Manhattan Loft Guy

modesty rewarded, but 'how well?' remains the question

Aug. 29, 2009
Categorized in: pricing analysis
Sometimes Manhattan Loft Guy gets it right. I posed a question on July 8 that was answered very quickly: will pricing 25% below 2007 hit The Market in a sweet spot? The answer came in an update on StreetEasy the very next day: contract signed. It sure is

Porter House loft may be "beyond the beyond" but sells off a million, up 40% or down 25%

Aug. 16, 2009
The Manhattan loft #3W at 66 Ninth Avenue (The Porter House) was marketed very enthusiastically at prices The Market was not ready for. It cleared on June 23 at $2.15mm, which is a difficult number to put in context. In the context of neighborly competiti

170 Fifth Avenue closes AT 2007 (maybe)

Aug. 13, 2009
Categorized in: Market Trends
If I am reading the listing descriptions and pictures correctly, the very recent sale of the Manhattan loft #5 at 170 Fifth Avenuefor $2.945mm was essentially flat since the February 2007 sale of #3 for $2,972,500. What has been preserved of the third flo

2005 pricing at The Printing House, 421 Hudson Street

Jul. 3, 2009
Categorized in: Market Trends
The Manhattan loft #709 at 421 Hudson Street cleared at $1.64mm on May 29, 2009. They wanted more, of course, having started at $1.995mm in October 2008. But they ended up at a price from about the middle of 2005.

(too rich, too thin) too stylish to sell (well)?

Jul. 1, 2009
Categorized in: pricing analysis
There is a lovely (anonymous!) Manhattan loft for sale that is almost a One Bed Wonder (haven't talked about one of those for a while). It is rather large, wonderfully renovated in a manner tres chic moderne, and has had a bit of trouble finding The Mar

price drop can re-set expectations IF low enough

Jun. 15, 2009
There's a Manhattan loft newly returned to market in a brand-name Tribeca building that has been for sale for quite a while. It is now on its third firm and fourth price. It is hard to see that the new firm and new price will have more luck than the last

neighborly competition / laggard at 144 West 18 Street closes off 15% since December

Jun. 11, 2009
Two Manhattan lofts at 144 West 18 Street (known, not poetically, as the Chainworks Building) closed 6 months apart. You won't be surprised to learn that the one that closed 6 months ago (#4N) closed higher than the one that closed last month (#3N), thoug

ending up where they started / $4mm closing at 99 Jane

Jun. 9, 2009
The Market just proved that the Manhattan loft #10A at 99 Jane Street is worth $4mm, as that is the clearing price just now publicly available from the May 30 closing. That strikes me as at least a bit odd, as this loft started to market a year ago at tha

pretty efficient (depressed) market at 505 Greenwich Street as both 6F and 7F sell, off 25%

May. 6, 2009
Categorized in: Market Trends
Here's another take on the theme of my neighborly competition thread: two all-but-identical Manhattan lofts at 505 Greenwich Street had overlapping marketing histories, prices and success, suggesting that even in this thin market The Market can be relativ

break away to win the neighborly competition / so many lofts, so many dollars ... but no sales (yet)

Apr. 17, 2009
Categorized in: pricing analysis
If this neighborly competition occurred in a cookie-cutter "apartment" building in Manhattan (even a high-end "apartment" building), the outcome would be clear: no one would bid on "B" or "D"; every serious bidder would bid on "F" and probably "E"; while

the problem of price discovery (hint: you have to pay attention)

Apr. 11, 2009
Categorized in: pricing analysis
I've been mulling a long-ish post on price discovery for quite a while (not writing it, obviously; just mulling). Pulling together some interesting riffs by other bloggers and news articles and market activity (and market inactivity), all in service of th

are they fooling only each other? / 3 neighbors push, 1 smiles

Jan. 7, 2009
Categorized in: Market Trends
I have been following a funky-but-spectacular (in its way) Manhattan loft and -- after noting the last price drop (and reading a little frustration between the lines of the marketing text) -- I checked on two other units in the same building also for sale

my job does not include magic tricks / pondering pricing puzzles

Dec. 15, 2008
Categorized in: Psychology of the market
One more question along these lines that is painfully relevant to the sale of Manhattan lofts and other apartments: If a seller really really really wants a price that is impossible to get in The Market, does that seller think the agent's job is to tell t

more unintended consequences in petri dish of Tribeca neighbors

Dec. 12, 2008
If I am the sellers of Loft 1 (priced only $30/ft below a neighbor with a terrace) or Loft 3 (priced $100/ft below a neighbor with a terrace) I would be worried that my listing will help sell Loft 4 to anyone who (all other things being equal) would prefe

selling the neighbor's loft / unintended consequences in a Tribeca petri dish?

Dec. 7, 2008
I remain fascinated by multiple units offered for sale in the same Manhattan loft building. I riffed on the possibility of one mistaken price leading to another on November 30 in neighborly competition leads to neighborly mistakes? the laboratory at 24 Ea

neighborly competition leads to neighborly mistakes? the laboratory at 24 East 22 Street

Nov. 30, 2008
Putting an apartment on the market at the same time as a neighbor's can strain relationships within a building. But I wonder about the degree to which competing listings can lead sellers to over-value their apartments. Let's get back to 24 East 22 Street