A great map tool that shows the area covered by the 43085 ZIP codes is on ZIP Code MAP. 

You will have to feed in the 43085 ZIP code to the 'Key Zip' box at the top to see the map of 43085 and the surrounding Central Ohio  ZIP codes.  I don't see a way of linking to a ZIP code map from the site or embedding a ZIP code map for 43085.  The mapping website say of ZIP codes:

"The USPS considers zip codes to be delivery routes instead of areas. There may be differences between this depiction and actual zip code mailing address."

"Zone Improvement Plan" is what ZIP code means. A ZIP code is not an area, it is a route... a mail route.

ZIP Code 43085

If your home or work ZIP code is 43085... you live or work in:

Columbus Ohio

OR

Worthington Ohio

OR

Sharon Township

OR

Village of  Riverlea

OR 

At one point I thought some of Perry Township was in the 43085 ZIP code... Properties just a smidge northwest of this property are in Sharon Township.

Perry Township ? residences in the Worthington School District may be in 43235 ZIP code only now since ZIP codes change,  properties are annexed.

Does it matter what ZIP code a house is in? Not that much in Central Ohio... your residence can be in the city of Columbus, in the Worthington School District and have a Westerville mailing address easily.

Does it matter what municipality you live in? Very much so for services, trash, police, fire, etc.

Almost all.... but not all of the 43085 ZIP code is also in the Worthington School District... Not all of the Worthington School District is in the 43085 ZIP code.

Worthington Forest Condominiums on the south east end of the 43085 ZIP code is in the Columbus School District. Theoretically there could be more residences along the edge of the 43085 ZIP code that are in other school districts...

Links to other Central Ohio Public School Districts

The Franklin County Auditors site gives what school district and municipality each residence in Central Ohio is located in. Better to check that than make assumptions based on a mailing address or ZIP code.

A Pasadena CA Realtor Irina Netchaev Twittered about Squid Zipper:  

Seth Godin announces free svc www.mayorofyourzipcode.com. free website to build info on your town. 07:41 AM February 12, 2008 from web

(Twitter is microblogging 140 characters...) 

Average sale price September 2005 in Worthington (City of Worthington ) was $263,570.  The highest sale price for a single family home was $585,000.  The lowest  sale price was $147,900.  This is from MLS, September 2005, single family homes.  There were 17 sales in the month of September.

Statistics for homes in the Worthington School district (but not in the City of Worthington) are

Average sale price September 2005 was  $205,560.  The highest sale price for a single family home was $373,500.   The lowest  sale price was  $125,000.   

The area that is Worthington Schools but is not in the City of Worthington includes homes in the City of Columbus and Perry and Sharon Townships including neighborhoods such as: Squirrel Hill, Worthington Run, Brookside Estates, Summerwood,   Smokey Row Estates, Western Hills, Smokey  Ridge Estates,  Smoky Mill Estates, Woodbridge Green, Olde Sawmill, Worthingview, Worthington Green, Olentangy Highlands,  Worthington Hills,   Old Woods, Stilson Highlands, Worthington Woods,  Worthington Park Place, Westworth Village,   Worthington Village, Worthington Crossing, Deer Creek and  Christopher  Woods.  There were 47 homes sold in September 2005 in Worthington Schools (but not in the city of Worthington.) 

The average home in both the city of Worthington and in the Worthington School District sold within two percent of the list price during the period.